Honolulu Jewelry Company Reviews: Cool Name, But Does the Jewelry Live Up to the Hype?

Who Is Honolulu Jewelry Company?

First off—props to the branding. Honolulu Jewelry Company sounds like it was founded by surfers who moonlight as master goldsmiths. You hear that name and immediately picture tropical sunsets, handcrafted heirlooms, and someone saying “mahalo” while handing you a pendant shaped like a wave.

But behind the vacation-friendly name is a company based in (yes, really) Honolulu, Hawaii. They specialize in island-inspired jewelry—think plumeria rings, maile leaf bangles, and sea turtle pendants—made in 14k gold or sterling silver. Their website looks like a local boutique, but their reach goes well beyond the islands thanks to Amazon and e-commerce.

Compared to other Amazon jewelry brands with sketchy factory locations and vague “Italian-style” claims, this one seems more legit. The big question: Is their jewelry actually worth the price—or is the name doing all the heavy lifting?

Honolulu Jewelry Company Reviews: Paradise or Pass?

Let’s take a peek at Honolulu Jewelry Company reviews from Amazon and around the web. Overall, they’re better than your typical $12 chain seller—but not without a few tropical hiccups.

🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 “Beautiful craftsmanship! Got the plumeria bracelet and love the attention to detail.”
They really lean into the flower-power aesthetic.

🌟🌟🌟🌟 “Nice quality, but a bit overpriced for how thin it is.”
It’s a light island breeze—don’t expect heavyweight chains.

🌟🌟 “Looked better online. Pendant was smaller than expected. Cute but not wow.”
Maybe the waves on the website made it look bigger?

🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 “Perfect gift. My mom loved the island feel and it came in a nice box.”
Hawaiian jewelry: approved by moms everywhere.

🌟🌟🌟 “Chain broke after 3 months of light use. A little disappointing at this price.”
Even paradise has its storms.

In short, Honolulu Jewelry Company is praised for its designs and Hawaiian flair, but some buyers question the weight-to-price ratio. Many pieces are dainty—great for gifting, but not ideal for those who want something with more presence (or less chance of snapping in a strong wind).

Honolulu Jewelry Company vs. ItaliaChains: Island Style vs. Italian Strength

Now let’s compare to ItaliaChains, the heavy-hitting silver specialists known for real Italian-made chains and old-school craftsmanship. It’s aloha vibes versus mamma mia metalsmithing.

Honolulu Jewelry Company:

• ✅ Real 925 sterling silver and 14k gold options

• ✅ Unique Hawaiian motifs (flowers, turtles, waves)

• ✅ Great gift packaging and branding

• ❌ Lightweight designs—many items feel delicate

• ❌ Prices are on the higher end for small pieces

• ❌ Not much for men’s bold styles or heavy chains

ItaliaChains:

• ✅ Handmade in Italy by real artisans

• ✅ Specializes in heavy rope, curb, franco, and figaro chains

• ✅ Real 925 silver and 14k gold vermeil

• ✅ Factory-direct pricing—heavier weight, same or lower price

• ❌ Doesn’t sell plumeria flowers (but they do sell chains that could pull a coconut)

If you want island charm, Honolulu Jewelry Company nails the look—but you’re paying more for design and branding than for raw silver weight. If you want bold, heavy, Italian-made silver, ItaliaChains wins every time. Especially when it comes to rope chains—you know, the ones that actually feel like jewelry, not ribbon.

Should You Buy From Honolulu Jewelry Company?

If you’re into floral bangles, cute pendants, or Hawaiian gifts, Honolulu Jewelry Company is a solid option. The name’s cool, the packaging’s classy, and the designs are perfect for tropical lovers, Mother’s Day, or anyone who watches Lilo & Stitch on repeat.

But if you’re after something that screams bold, classic, and hip hop—or you want a rope chain you can actually feel—check out ItaliaChains. Their pieces may not have hibiscus flowers, but they’ve got the weight, shine, and quality you’ll wear forever.

Because let’s be real: nothing says aloha like a chain that won’t break when you take off your hoodie.