Whats The Best Jewelry Store In Cape Coral , FL? We Review The Best Jeweler In Cape Coral - Top 10 List!

Whether you're shopping for a meaningful gift, an engagement ring, or upgrading your chain game, Cape Coral is home to some standout jewelry stores. Gold and silver chains are staple pieces for these jewelers and many of these guys also offer custom pieces.  From family-owned shops to expert craftsmen and trusted online retailers, here are the 10 best jewelers for gold, silver, and diamond jewelry in Cape Coral, Florida.

1. John Michael’s Diamond and Jewelry Studio

📍 1331 NE Pine Island Rd #1, Cape Coral, FL 33909
Known for their custom pieces and diamond engagement rings, John Michael’s is a local favorite.

• GIA-certified diamonds and bridal jewelry

• Custom design and in-house repair services

• Friendly, no-pressure staff with decades of experience

2. The Jewelry Repair Center

📍 1232 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral, FL 33904
A go-to spot for quick, reliable repairs and unique estate jewelry.

• Expert jewelry & watch repair

• Wide selection of vintage and modern gold pieces

• Honest service and fair prices

3. Cape Jewelers

📍 1311 Del Prado Blvd S, Cape Coral, FL 33990
A trusted family-owned jeweler offering everything from moissanite to high-end diamonds.

• Known for engagement rings, pendants & bracelets

• Repairs, custom design, and resizing done on-site

• Excellent selection of 14k gold and silver jewelry

4. Gator Jewelry & Loan

📍 925 SE 47th Terrace, Cape Coral, FL 33904
This hybrid pawn/jewelry shop surprises many with its luxury finds at great prices.

• Authentic gold & diamond jewelry at discounted rates

• Great for one-of-a-kind or vintage pieces

• Friendly staff and fast service

5. ItaliaChains (Online – Ships to Cape Coral, FL)

🌐 www.italiachains.com
Even though not physically located in Florida, ItaliaChains is popular among Cape Coral residents thanks to fast, affordable shipping and premium Italian-made jewelry.

• Specializes in 925 sterling silver, gold vermeil, and moissanite iced-out jewelry

• Ships nationwide—fast delivery to Florida and thousands of happy customers

• Factory-direct pricing with no middlemen means better value

6. Foxy Lady Jewelers

📍 4606 SE 47th Terrace, Cape Coral, FL 33904
A boutique jewelry shop that’s big on personality and handcrafted style.

• Hand-picked gemstone and diamond jewelry

• Personalized service and unique designs

• Known for charm bracelets and artisan rings

7. J.R. Diamond Jewelers

📍 1515 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral, FL 33904
A Cape Coral staple with a strong reputation for quality and fair pricing.

• Custom bridal sets and anniversary pieces

• Offers financing and appraisals

• Polished customer service with high local ratings

8. Walmart Jewelry Department (Various Locations)

📍 Many locations across Cape Coral
Don’t overlook Walmart for everyday gold and silver jewelry needs on a budget.

• Affordable 10k gold, sterling silver, and cubic zirconia

• Convenient for chain replacements and earrings

• Ideal for quick gifts or backups

9. Touch of Class Jewelers (Nearby in Fort Myers)

📍 13300 S Cleveland Ave #47, Fort Myers, FL 33907
Only a short drive away, this store has been serving Lee County since 1983.

• Large showroom of diamond, gold, and silver jewelry

• On-site repairs and custom engagement rings

• Family-owned with a solid local reputation

10. JCPenney Fine Jewelry – Coralwood Mall

📍 2301 Del Prado Blvd S, Cape Coral, FL 33990
This department store has a surprisingly solid fine jewelry section.

• Affordable diamond rings and gold chains

• Seasonal deals and warranties available

• Convenient location for shoppers in the area

Final Thoughts

Cape Coral has no shortage of excellent jewelers—whether you're after timeless diamonds, Italian silver chains, or trendy moissanite studs. Local favorites like John Michael’s and Cape Jewelers offer personalized service, while online shops like ItaliaChains give you access to premium pieces without ever leaving your house.

No matter your style or budget, these are the best jewelers in Cape Coral, FL to explore for your next fine jewelry purchase